How to play Secret Santa with college friends?

Doing Secret Santa is a great way to unwind after the exhausting finals and have a good time with close friends. In this guide, you will find tried-and-true tips to help you organize a memorable Secret Santa exchange, choose great presents, and keep things secret until the exchange day.

Secret Santa with college friends

When organizing this year’s Christmas party with friends, don’t forget to plan the Secret Santa activity. This gift-giving tradition is a guaranteed recipe for laughter, inside jokes, and memories that last for years. Plus, it is a great way to save for students on a budget, as everyone buys only one gift for the assigned friend.

Secret Santa is not for office clerks and family gatherings only. It lets everyone unleash the gift-giving genius, fosters stronger bonds with your college mates, and adds a touch of mystery (does Alison know that I am giving her a gift? She’s been talking about how much she wants that makeup palette for Christmas). In this article, you will find a step-by-step guide to planning a smooth gift exchange and ensuring that everyone gets a great personalized gift.

How to organize a killer Secret Santa with college friends?

Without further ado, here’s how to organize this year’s Secret Santa with friends:

Invite participants

For the Secret Santa exchange, you need a minimum of four people, but more is usually better. You might invite a group of your close friends, or members of your class, or mix various social circles and get together people with diverse backgrounds. Ask around ASAP so that everyone has time to discuss the details and buy presents before Christmas.

Set a gift budget

Establishing the gift amount is necessary to keep the exchange equal and avoid hurt feelings when someone gets an overly cheap gift. However, money is a sensitive subject, so make sure to discuss the budget in advance. Many students live on a budget and won’t be comfortable spending much on presents. Meet in person or schedule a FaceTime call to discuss it and ensure that the amount works for everyone.

Tip: Usually, $10 to $20 is a great budget for college friends, but the amount might be different for your group.

Draw names

Draw names for Secret Santa

Once you invited all attendees and agreed on the budget, it’s time to draw names. The most convenient way is to use the online generator, such as the MySanta app. However, you might use a hat and write names on pieces of paper if you prefer the old-school way to play.

With an online organizer, you can invite players by email and then draw names in one click. Keeping things secret is the core part of the fun, so instruct everyone NOT to tell whom they got! The results of the draw are saved, so there is no way someone forgets for whom they should buy a gift. Plus, in an online generator, everyone can add their gift wishes (e.g. a portable phone charger, blanket, fiction books, or a gift certificate).

Try our MySanta app
Create wishlists and exchange gifts with college friends this year! Set exceptions, chat with your giftee secretly, and track gifts to ensure that everyone buys a present on time.
Start
Try our MySanta app

Set the game rules

The good thing about Secret Santa is that you can personalize it however you like. Moreover, some extra rules keep the gift exchange (and the party) organized and unique. For one, you can set the gift theme – everyone brings green gifts, gag gifts, Marvel-themed gifts, or gifts that start with a T letter. Next, you can encourage everyone to attach a clue to the wrapped gift to make guessing even more tricky.

Ask everyone to have their gifts ready a few days before the Christmas gathering. It will help avoid situations when someone forgets to buy a present or grabs a last-minute one.

Tip: Have a couple of small spare gifts just in case – no matter the circumstances, nobody should leave the party empty-handed!

Share hints and wishlists

Now, the trickiest and most exciting part – choosing a present for your assigned friend or college mate. If you were lucky to draw a close friend, you probably know what they want. If not, rely on gift suggestions that the person wrote on paper next to their name or in the online generator. Try to learn more about the person casually, or use the anonymous chat in the Secret Santa generator. Encourage everyone to create wishlists – it will save time for each player!

If you don’t know the person well, make sure they will appreciate any gift and the effort you put in. Think out of the box and try to make the gift as personalized as possible. Christmas is all about giving, and preparing a good gift lets you appreciate this tradition.

Also Read:
White Elephant Gift Exchange Ideas & Game Rules
Read
White Elephant Gift Exchange Ideas & Game Rules

Plan the fun reveal

Encourage everyone to bring a wrapped gift with a recipient’s name on it to the party and let the fun reveal begin! Each player unwraps their gift and guesses who got it, which is accompanied by bursts of laughter and creates new inside jokes. To sparkle up the big reveal, combine the Secret Santa with Christmas Trivia questions or clues. Spread the holiday cheer while keeping the suspense high!

Here are some ideas to make a reveal hilarious:

  • Set the holiday theme. Encourage everyone to wear Winter Wonderland costumes, the 80’s outfits, or ugly sweaters (nothing can beat the classics).
  • Add clues to the gift. Everyone should solve a puzzle, a riddle, or answer trivia questions before unwrapping the gift. Such challenges work great for a small group of friends.
  • Plan more activities and games. Unwrapping presents is the core activity, but you might want to plan a movie night, fun contests, and group activities to keep everyone entertained.
  • Capture the moment! Take pictures of your group, including the most awkward moments and surprised faces as your friends stare at their gifts. Create memories that last!

Plan the gift exchange day in advance so that everyone has free time to get together and celebrate. Christmas holidays are hectic, and it will be a pity if someone cannot make it.

Also Read:
12 Fun Christmas Games With Friends To Make Your Party Unforgettable
Read
12 Fun Christmas Games With Friends To Make Your Party Unforgettable

What to give a college friend for Secret Santa

Picking a perfect present is easier when you got a close friend. If you have no idea what to give (or the person didn’t provide hints), use it as an opportunity to bring a super helpful or, on the contrary, fun and ridiculous gift. Or, use our gift ideas that most college students will appreciate:

Gift ideas for students

Experience gifts Tickets to their favorite artist, sporting event, bowling, mixology, or music production class
Dorm room gifts A warm blanket, decent pillow, desk organizer, personalized mug, or coffee cup
Food and drinks A box of their favorite chocolates, gourmet coffee, or a gift certificate to Uber Eats
Practical presents Academic diary, phone charger, kitchen appliances, bath and shower sets, or gift card

When choosing a gift for a college mate, consider their interests and wishes. A personalized present can strengthen your friendship and bring positive emotions for the next year.

Playing Secret Santa with friends remotely

If you cannot meet in one location for Christmas, organize a virtual gift exchange! With an online Secret Santa organizer, you can exchange gifts with people living in different states and continents.

Here’s how to set up your virtual exchange:

  1. Create a virtual Secret Santa game in the MySanta app and invite players by email. Each participant will need to add their mailing address.
  2. Encourage everyone to fill out wishlists and share gift ideas. When you cannot meet in person, it is harder to guess what the person wants for Christmas. With a wishlist, you won’t have to guess and can simply buy what your friend wants.
  3. Draw names to find out who gives to whom. Everyone sends presents to the recipient in advance so that there are no delays in delivery.
  4. Plan a video call to meet online, celebrate the holiday, and unwrap the gifts! Thus, you can share joy and laughter even in the distance. Plan some virtual activities (such as Christmas Trivia, Never Have I Ever, or holiday bingo to have a great time together.

Playing a Secret Santa will help you chill out and have a good time after the exhausting finals, part-time jobs, and other difficulties of student life, and the great memories will last long after the semester ends. Plus, a heartwarming exchange will help you show appreciation for your friends and strengthen bonds while celebrating the holiday season.

FAQs

What can I give to a college mate I don’t know well?

Choose a practical gift that appeals to everyone, such as a coffee mug, a fun desk organizer, a gift card to a coffee shop or Amazon, or a small snack basket with a funny personalized card. If you often meet in person, casually ask around. Avoid anything too personal (such as perfume or self-care items) or potentially offensive.

What if someone wants to go over budget for a Secret Santa gift?

Christmas is the time to give and be generous. Yet, ask everyone to stick to the agreed-upon budget to keep the game fair for everyone. If someone is willing to spend more, they could buy a separate personal gift in addition to the Secret Santa present and hand it to the giftee separately.

What if someone forgets to bring a gift to the party?

Have a few backup gifts in case someone forgets to bring a present. Thus, the fun won’t be spoiled and nobody will feel left out. You can also ask the forgetful Santa to buy sweet treats or a drink for the giftee to make up for it and encourage everyone to keep enjoying the event.

How do you make Secret Santa more fun for college students?

Agree to exchange gag, humorous, or creative gifts. You can also play the White Elephant game that includes swapping and stealing gifts from each other. Thus, everyone will focus on creating a light-hearted and fun atmosphere. Award the prize for the most desirable gift, most creative gift, and most likely to be re-gifted present.