How To Play Secret Santa in Creative and Sports Communities

Communities come together naturally: since childhood, people join clubs, art studios, and sports groups. They meet, practice, joke around, and over time develop shared rituals that hold them together.

One of these rituals is Secret Santa – a game that lets you show attention to others, delight them, and notice their unique traits. Each participant gets a gift and a joy of preparing a surprise for another member of the community.

In this article, we’ll explain the game mechanics in detail, compare the traditional format with the online version, and offer ready-made Secret Santa scenarios for creative and sports communities.

Why Secret Santa Works Well in Clubs and Communities

Secret Santa is often associated with offices, classrooms, or circles of friends. But the game works just as well in larger communities united by shared interests, like creative groups or sports clubs. Adding a holiday tradition like Secret Santa can strengthen the bond in your group and help you know each other better.

For creative groups, Secret Santa becomes a stage for self-expression. Members can design original gifts, create handmade packaging, or add playful twists to the gift exchange. For sports teams, the game can serve as a team building: gifts reflect shared achievements, future goals, or funny moments.

Also Read:

How To Make Secret Santa More Fun: Activities and Ideas Beyond Gift Exchange

Read

Classic Game or Online Service: Which One to Choose for Your Community

Before organizing Secret Santa for sports teams or creative clubs, choose the game format. There are two major ways to play - a traditional Secret Santa with a hat and with an online generator. Keep reading to see where the classic approach falls short and why an online service may be a more convenient alternative for your community.

The Traditional Secret Santa Format

The simplest way to set up a gift exchange is to gather in one room and draw names from the Christmas hat. That way, players instantly know who gives a gift to whom. Yet, this method has its downsides:

• Pieces of papers with names on them can get lost.
• Someone will draw their own name — and everyone will have to redraw.
• There’s no way to set exceptions for the draw.
• It’s hard to tell who forgot to bring a gift if something goes wrong.

That's why people tend to use online services these days, especially for larger groups.

An Online Secret Santa Generator

An online organizer, such as the MySanta app, can track game progress and assign Santas in seconds. Moreover, you can play remotely. Here are other advantages of using an online generator:

• Invite players instantly via link or QR code.
• Find out what your giftee wants – players complete questionnaires and wishlists.
• The draw supports exceptions so you can avoid awkward situations.
• Anonymous chats let you talk to your Santa, your recipient, or the whole group.
• Gift status is visible to the organizer so it's easy to track progress.
• Convenient game moderation and dashboard keeps the game convenient.

How To Play Secret Santa With Your Team Using an App

The MySanta service takes on everything that usually drains an organizer’s time and energy: the draw, reminders, delivery control, and even anonymous messaging. You can choose a game format for your situation, set the rules, collect wishlists, and be confident no one will be left without a gift.

Here's how it works:

1. Create a game and choose the format. Pick at the start: either a full Online Game with questionnaires and wishlists, or a Quick Game — a lightning-fast draw for up to 9 people when everyone’s together and you just need to assign pairs.
2. Agree on how gifts will be delivered. You can play in person if everyone is in the same city, or send gifts by mail.
3. Set the budget and deadlines. Keep the budget affordable for everyone in the group.
4. Share the link with players. The organizer sets the budget and join deadlines and invites players by email, link, or QR code.
5. Answer a few questions and complete wishlists. Each participant fills out a short profile and builds a wishlist with links to specific items.
6. Add exclusions and draw names. With a PRO plan, the organizer can set as many exceptions as needed so that people who don't get along won't give to each other.
7. For the final exchange, host a small party. Plan creative activities to make the gift exchange an unforgettable event.

Try our MySanta app

You can create wishlists, add exclusions, and communicate with your gifree secretly. Moreover, there is an option to track gifts and ensure that everyone buys a present on time.

Start

Game Scenarios for Creative and Sports Communities

Secret Santa is built to work in any situation because you can adapt the rules for your group. Feel free to choose a gift theme, plan a fun reveal, or add riddles and challenges.

Below are examples of how the same game mechanics become especially useful for different creative and sports communities.

Theater or Dance Studio

Tours, competitions, pre-holiday sessions — in this period, hybrid format is best, with some members of the group playing in person and some remotely. Set deadlines and budget, add exclusions, and launch the draw. The key is to choose a distance-friendly way to hand off gifts.

Photo Club

Participants make wishlists with specific links — from photo paper to favorite marker brands and shooting accessories. If questions remain, ask them anonymously in chat to keep the intrigue. Encourage people to share their favorite festive photos and tell stories associated with them – it helps connect on a personal level.

Music Group

As usual, part of the team is in the studio, part is on tour. In this case, it’s convenient to choose gifts with shipping in mind, focusing first on each other’s wishlists. In the shipping section, leave the tracking number and mark “sent” so the recipient won’t stress about timing between gigs or rehearsals.

Running Club

Members often live in different cities, and the race season doesn’t stop — winter or summer. The service helps collect questionnaires, organize tracked delivery, and clearly shows whose gift is still en route. The finale can be a club meetup: a group run followed by the gift exchange and a holiday party.

Soccer, Basketball, or Volleyball Team

To avoid awkward pairings, set exclusions before the draw. And you can leave a respected coach out of the general draw altogether if they don’t want to choose a gift for players — organize a separate surprise from the whole team. The game gets even more fun if athletes invite their significant others to join in.

Fitness Club

If the whole group meets for workouts in one gym, it’s convenient to launch a Quick Game right on the spot — the draw takes just a couple of minutes. For a network of clubs or groups with different schedules, choose the Online Game — everyone joins when it’s convenient, and the organizer easily tracks the exchange.

Kids’ Class or School Team

A great idea is to run Secret Santa in the very first year of classes or training together. It helps children get acquainted faster, make friends, and feel like part of the team. It’s convenient when the coach or homeroom teacher sees who has joined the game, who has sent a gift, and who has received — full control of the process. That way there’s no need to keep bothering parents for help with organizing — they’re often overloaded already.

Setting exclusions and using anonymous chats lets you account for the nuances of kids’ interactions and avoid awkward situations.

Gift Ideas for Creative Groups

A thoughtful gift in a creative setting should both inspire and feel personal. Here are some festive examples:

• Sketchbook with a Personal Note — A place to capture new ideas, made warmer by a handwritten message inside.
• Set of Quality Brushes or Pens — Something practical that also shows you recognize the recipient’s craft.
• Art-Inspired Jewelry or Accessories — Small items that celebrate their passion, like earrings shaped like paint palettes.
• Custom Playlist or Poem — Free to make, but meaningful if it reflects the recipient’s tastes.

Gift Ideas for Sports Communities

Sports-related gifts don’t have to be expensive — it’s enough to be thoughtful and in tune with the group’s shared passion.

• Personalized Water Bottle — Both practical and easy to customize with team symbols.
• Sports Socks or Gear — Useful items every athlete goes through quickly.
• Funny Training Accessories — Like a whistle keychain or towel with an inside joke.
• Massage Ball or Recovery Band — A nod to self-care after workouts.

These presents carry both humor and practicality, keeping the holiday exchange fun and connected to the sport.

Conclusion

Secret Santa is one of the beloved holiday traditions in clubs and communities. Whether you want to play with a music band, a student photo club, a kids’ sports team, or fifty soccer players — with the MySanta service, your game process will be clear and enjoyable. By adapting the game to your community’s culture, you turn a gift exchange into a memorable celebration that unites everyone.

FAQs